Expert Enironmental Law advice

YALE TOUR TO ROATAN ISLAND, HONDURAS

Fri March 31st 2017


In March 2017 Sue Simons was offered the unique opportunity to join a Yale University Educational Travel Tour of Roatan Island off the coast of Honduras in the Caribbean.

Forty miles off the coast of mainland Honduras, Roatan Island has been experiencing exponential growth in tourism. Fortunately it doesn’t enjoy the same reputation of mainland Honduras as the murder capital of the world.

The tour was led by Professor Daniel C. Esty, Hillhouse Professor of Environmental Law and Policy, School of Forestry & Environmental Studies and Clinical Professor of Environmental Law & Policy, Yale Law School. Professor Esty was hosted by Berry Simons and Beca at an event held in Auckland in March 2016.

The team comprised Yale Alumni and invitees and stayed at Tranquilseas Eco Lodge at Sandy Bay on Roatan Island which overlooks the world’s second largest coral reef system. The reef runs along the Cayman Trench which drops down 25,000ft.

Each evening there was a lecture on local environmental issues from a Roatan local with an interest in the wellbeing of the island and the reef in particular. Speakers included Mickey Charteris, the author of ‘Caribean Reef Life: of the Bay Islands, Honduras, who addressed the risks to the reef from tourism, development and overfishing.

His views were mirrored in a lecture by a representative from the Roatan Marine Park, a service which is woefully underfunded. One of the obvious obstacles to protecting the delicate reef system is to educate the Islanders on sustainable fishing practices which, given the overwhelming profile of poverty on the island, is an uphill battle with such limited resources available. The Honduran Government is encouraging tourism without investing in the necessary infrastructure and there are almost no controls on the way development is managed.

Professor Esty engaged the team in a discussion about the global trends on environmental protection, in particular whether such protection is a luxury that many countries could not afford. Honduras as a whole has a record of environmental protection which is downward trending. An unnerving statistic that 127 environmental activists have been murdered in Honduras since 2009 illustrates the point.

As Sue observed:

“The recent OECD Report which has been highly critical of New Zealand’s environmental track record was released while I was on Roatan. Within that company, I was frankly embarrassed and it occurred to me listening to these lectures and discussions how unfortunate it is that New Zealand appears to be behaving like a ‘developing’ nation with a downward trending attitude to environmental protection.”

On a lighter note, the days were spent snorkelling and diving the reef at various points around the island. A real highlight was the opportunity to take a submarine, the ‘Idabel’, to a depth of 2,200ft into total darkness down into the Cayman Trench. The submarine was built and is owned by Captain Karl Stanley who offered an opportunity that less than 10,000 people have ever experienced. As Sue reflected:

“This was the most extraordinary experience, like travelling through outer space and the absolute highlight of the trip.”

The descent took 45 minutes and while the temperature was 28˚C at the surface socks and jackets were required at 2,200ft. Life at that depth, which has adapted to the extreme pressure, cold and absence of light, is quite different from anything seen at the surface.

On the final day of the tour the team took a boat to the Cayos Cochinos, a large marine reserve dotted with islands, one of which is populated by the Garifuna people who are a community descended from 17th century released or escaped slaves. They offered lunch and showed the team around their island.

In the afternoon a pod of over 60 dolphins followed the boat back to the main island through a “tuna boil” which served to provide dinner for the team.

Sue said:

“Overall, it has to be said, that the 10 days on Roatan not only offered me insight into a completely different world but gave a global context to the work we do in Environmental law in New Zealand.”

Experience & expertise


Three exceptional partners lead Berry Simons’ team of talented, motivated lawyers. Because Berry Simons is focused solely around Resource Management and Environmental law, we have the intellectual horsepower and resources of the equivalent team in a large firm. The difference is in our client relationships – which are stronger, and closer. Decisions are made with client executives and partners involved throughout your project, seated at the same table.

our people