Espin obtains consent for digital billboard in Wairau Valley near SH1
Thu Feb. 10th 2022
Consent was granted despite opposition and negative recommendations.
Simon Berry and Tamsin Gorman led a multi-disciplinary team to obtain consent for Espin Holdings NZ Limited to establish a digital billboard in the Wairau Valley on Auckland’s North Shore. The site is not far from State Highway 1.
The consent was granted in the face of opposition from Waka Kotahi and negative recommendations from Auckland Council and Auckland Transport (AT).
The application was publicly notified by Auckland Council due to concerns about traffic safety as a result of potential driver distraction. Only two opposing submissions were received, including one from Waka Kotahi which was described in the submissions of counsel for Espin as “somewhat hysterical”. However, Waka Kotahi did not attend the hearing. Given Waka Kotahi’s non-attendance, the Hearing Panel determined that “no weight” should be accorded to the Waka Kotahi submission.
In relation to the issue routinely raised by Auckland Council and AT that the billboard would pose a traffic safety hazard as a result of driver distraction, Brett Harries’ evidence was that the assertions made by Council / AT witnesses were based on perception and assumption rather than fact and there is no proven causal link between digital billboards (as they are operated in New Zealand) and driver distraction.
The Panel also accepted Espin’s submission that this application could be distinguished from that considered by the Environment Court in Prime Property Group Limited v Wellington City Council  NZEnvC 169, in which resource consent for a digital billboard was declined. That case could be distinguished from the proposal for a number of reasons, particularly the difference in speed limits and crash records.
Simon Berry said:
"It is disappointing that Auckland Council and AT officers continue to trot out information that has been rejected again and again in the light of objective evidence. I consider that it is irresponsible for Council and AT officers to continue to repeat the same old garbage about driver distraction when they must know that it is simply unfounded and incorrect.
We were impressed by the acuity of the Panel’s questioning at the hearing and the quality of the decision and are pleased that good sense prevailed in the end.”
News & Updates
An innovative culture: Reflections 10 years on
On the tenth anniversary of Berry Simons commencing operations, the founders reflect on the firm's unique practice model - and the doubters who said it wouldn't work.
Mon May 30th 2022
Simon Berry chairs Environmental Law & Policy Conference 2022
A packed programme highlighted the massive workload looming for the Government and Resource Management community.
Wed May 25th 2022
Rezoning obtained for residential development at Drury East
Sue Simons and Kate Storer have successfully obtained rezoning of land for residential development at Drury East.
Mon May 9th 2022
Fast-Track consent granted for Brickfields development in Hobsonville
Berry Simons assists developer to obtain consent under the Fast-track consenting legislation.
Thu May 5th 2022